Performance:
The question is how did it work in comparison to a cantenna?
Initially things didn't look too good, the repeater wasn't working too well with lots of dropped packets. I connected my laptop up directly to the antenna and was getting about -83dB, my Orinoco card works just fine at that but of course this was feeding a Linksys WAP11 so a whole different ball game.
I held the antenna at arms length away from the window (the line of sight is tight already, pretty much the angle shown in the picture directly above where the antenna is mounted on my fridge) and as soon as I got just an arms length away, the signal shot up and all was well, so the only problem was that my mounting was a bit short and needed to project a bit more for my application.
To compare the antenna against a cantenna design, it's much much more directional. Cantenna's can be aimed anywhere roughly in the right direction and will immediately start to work, the parabolic dish snaps in at the right point but is pretty weak otherwise.
From my limited testing the gain seems to be about 2dB greater than the cantenna although in order to connect my parabolic antenna to the laptop, I had to use a couple of adaptors and a pigtail to the Orinoco so it's quite possible that the signal might be a total of 3dB greater, which of course, is double the signal!
In terms of difficulty to build, as I said, I over-engineered a solution, Michaels template can be made of out foil covered card like I used for the cardboard horn antenna and thus can be made in about 10 minutes too.
In summary a bit of fun for me to build and a great template and contribution to the wireless community from Michael.
Thanks to - www.nodomainname.co.uk |